By Isaac Meler, Special envoy to Madrid
November 2nd, 2017
That the Spanish National Court (AN – Audiència Nacional) is the court with jurisdiction to judge the crimes of sedition and rebellion is not expressly established in any law. For that reason, the investigating judge, Carmen Lamela, has had to resort to the Francoist criminal code to retain control of the investigation of these crimes alledgedly committed by the president of the Generalitat, Carles Puigdemont, and his advisers, when they declare independence [from Spain].
Lamela’s argument is based on two elements and these are the same which she used to be able to investigate the presidents of the ANC and Òmnium, Jordi Sànchez and Jordi Cuixart, whom she remanded to pre-emptive custody without bail, as well as her investigation of Catalan Police Major Josep Lluís Trapero, and his lieutenant Teresa Laplana.
First, she asserts that the law of the judicial jurisdiction, attributes to the National Court, the competence to judge “crimes against the form of Government”. She also refers to the 1973 criminal code which has a section called “Crimes against the Head of State, successor, High Organizations of the nation and the form of government.” This section includes an article which penalizes acts “directly aimed” at “unlawfully changing the organization of the State.” But compare these to the descriptions of rebellion and sedition, of which Puigdemont and colleagues are accused, because the former punishes the use of violence to declare the independence from a part of the State, while only the second refers to alterations to the form of government.
However, the judge leaves aside two other elements that challenge her jurisdiction. First of all, in the current penal code, the crime of sedition appears under the heading “Crimes against public order” and the second [sedition], under “Crimes against the Constitution”, and are described differently than those established by the law of the judicial jurisdiction, which preceded the criminal code of 1973. She also omitted the fact that the National Court itself, expressly rejected its own jurisdiction to judge the crimes of rebellion in a hearing in December of 2008. “The crime of rebellion has never been within the competence of this National Court”, the court declared in a writ by magistrate Javier Gómez Bermúdez as president of the Criminal Court, at that time.

The Court rejected the prosecution of the crime of rebellion during an investigation opened regarding the crimes of the Franco regime by judge Baltasar Garzón. It has become clear that the current penal code is above pre-constitutional criminal laws. However Lamela has consciously decided to go against the jurisprudence of the judicial body to which she belongs.

Photos: Fragments of the text from the 2008 jurisprudence, which Carmen Lamela now contradicts by ruling the National Court is the court with jurisdiction to rule on cases of rebellion.
Also, remember that the National Court already opened investigations for sedition and rebellion in 2015 for the motions approved in Catalan city councils in support of the pro-independence process. For example, the investigation already in process on the charge of sedition against the councilor of CUP (Popular Unity Candidacy party) in Vic, Joan Coma, who said “you can’t make an omelette without breaking some eggs.” At that time, Judge Ismael Moreno also appealed to the Francoist criminal code to investigate the charge, as a result of the complaint filed to the Guardia Civil, by the far-right founder of the Plataforma per Catalunya, Josep Anglada.
Original text: http://www.naciodigital.cat/noticia/141865/jutge/lamela/recorre/al/codi/penal/franquista/jutjar/govern/rebellio

